The full title is Genso Suikoden: Tsumugareshi Hyakunen no Toki, which has something to do with time spun over a hundred years or something like that. Sounds more impressive than it really is, seriously. If I hadn’t played Shining Blade already, this would be my blah-est game of the year. I’ve had a pretty good 2013, all things considered, but I knew I couldn’t get away without a few clunkers.
Story so far
I’m only 12 hours in and just got a strategist, so things might change. My protagonist lives in a world where deadly monsters show up every 100 years and, of course, this is the 100th year. Finding the monsters too much for them to take on, they warp back into the past with the aid of a magic tree and get training from the heroes of 100 years ago on how to fight the monsters. It then turns out that a group, the Crimson Axe is manipulating these monsters with the aim of overthrowing the Aonian Empire. MC and his gang don’t trust either group, so they strike out on their own to defeat the Crimson Axe and their monsters and bring back peace to the world.
It looks nice on paper, as stories like this tend to do. But just like business is all about location, location, location, stories are all about execution, execution, execution. Once my party discovers how to travel into the past, their solution to every single problem is always “Travel back 100 years and get someone to help us fix it.” It makes them look weak and lame when they can’t stand on their own two feet and are constantly running back crying to the heroes of yesteryear. That leads to:
Problem 1: The older heroes are far more colorful, far more heroic and far, far more reliable than my gang of wet-behind-the-ears village kids. It’s not because they’re all at level 50; they just happen to be better characters. Cheerful, easy-going Troward is a much better main character than dull, goody two-shoes Trunks (not his name, but I should totally have named him that). Troward’s best friend Rolf is a much nicer fellow than cranky tsundere mage Myura. And so on it goes for the whole cast. The reason why the game immediately rules out importing any of those ancient heroes to the future is because that’s the first thing any sensible gamer would do. There’s simply no contest.